The Menu

Ranch Cheese Curds

V → Ranch-seasoned Wisconsin White Cheddar fried golden brown & served w/ our famous Ranch Dressing

Mexican Street Corn Dip

GS V → housemade Roasted Corn & fresh Mexican Cotija Cheese dip served w/ warm Tortilla Chips

Pickle Fries

V → lightly Battered & fried golden brown, w/ Ranch Dressing

Smoked Whitefish Dip

→ smoked in house & served chilled, w/ fresh-Fried Pita Chips

Smoked Chicken Wings

GS → Six or Twelve Wings from off our smoker, served w/ your choice of Dipping Sauce

Pretzels & Beer Cheese

V → two giant soft Pretzel Sticks w/ warm Beer Cheese Dip

Onion Rings

V → basket of crispy-fried Onion Rings, w/ Ranch Dressing

Cheese Quesadilla

V → grilled Flour Tortilla stuffed w/ melted Cheddar-Jack Cheese, Tomatoes, Onions, w/ Sour Cream & Salsa — option to add grilled Chicken or pulled Pork

Kettle Chips & Beer Cheese

V → our housemade Kettle Chips w/ warm Beer Cheese Dip

Fried Portabella Mushrooms

→ basket of crispy-fried breaded Mushrooms, w/ Ranch Dressing

Soup of the Day

→ made in house daily, served in a cup or a bowl

Taco Salad

→ crispy Tortilla Bowl, Iceberg Lettuce, Cheddar-Jack Cheese, Tomatoes, Onions, & choice of seasoned Ground Beef or shredded Chicken, w/ choice of Dressing

Nuts and Berries Salad

GF V → fresh Greens, Michigan Dried Cherries, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Toasted Pecans, w/ Raspberry Vinaigrette — option to add grilled Chicken

Chicken Tender Salad

→ fresh Greens, crispy Chicken Tenders, Cheddar-Jack Cheese, Tomatoes, Scallions, w/ choice of Dressing

Smoked Chicken Street Tacos

→ chopped Smoked Chicken Thighs off our smoker in Flour Tortillas w/ Cotija Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, fresh Cilantro, & Jalapeño Crema, served w/ Chips & Salsa

Ploughman’s Grilled Cheese

V → Havarti Cheese, Apricot-Black Pepper Preserves, Gala Apples, & Pickled Red Onion on grilled Sourdough

Smoked Bologna Sandwich

→ a thick slice of Bologna from off our smoker, grilled & glazed w/ our own Bourbon Barbecue Sauce, & topped w/ housemade Coleslaw on a homestyle Bun

Barbecue Pulled Pork Sandwich

→ our own pulled Pork covered in tangy Barbecue Sauce on a homestyle Bun w/ a side of housemade Coleslaw

Grain Elevator

→ grilled Ham & Turkey, American & Swiss Cheese, crispy Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, & Mayonnaise on grilled Sourdough

Philly Cheesesteak

→ thinly-sliced Ribeye grilled w/ Green Peppers & Onions, topped w/ melted Provolone Cheese on a grilled hoagie bun — option to add grilled Jalapeños & Cajun Seasoning

California Reuben

→ thinly-sliced Turkey Breast, Swiss Cheese, & Housemade Coleslaw on grilled Rye

Classic Reuben

→ thinly-sliced Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut, & Thousand Island Dressing on Grilled Rye

Boxcar BLT

→ crispy Applewood-Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, & Mayonnaise on grilled Sourdough

Meatball Marinara Sub

→ a half dozen of our smoked-in-house Pork & Beef Meatballs cooked in housemade Marinara Sauce, topped w/ Provolone Cheese in a grilled Hoagie Bun

Fried Walleye Sandwich

→ crispy-fried hand-breaded Walley Fillet, Lettuce, Tomato, & Tartar Sauce in a grilled Hoagie Bun

Mexican Chicken & Corn Wrap

→ grilled Chicken Breast, Cheddar-Jack, our Mexican Street Corn Dip, Black Beans, Lettuce, Tomato, & Jalapeño Crema

Club Wrap

→ sliced Turkey & Ham, crispy Bacon, Cheddar-Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Mayo

Barbecue Pulled Pork Wrap

→ smoked Barbecue Pulled Pork, Cheddar-Jack Cheese, & housemade Coleslaw

Chicken Ranch Wrap

→ crispy Chicken Tenders, Lettuce, Tomato, Cheddar-Jack Cheese, & Ranch Dressing

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

→ Chicken Tenders tossed in Buffalo Sauce, w/ Lettuce, Tomato, Cheddar-Jack Cheese, & Ranch Dressing

Dad Joke Burger

→ w/ American, Swiss, Provolone, Beer Cheese Sauce, & Caramelized Onions

Smoked Cheese & Mushroom Burger

→ w/ Cream Cheese from off our Smoker, Sauteed Mushrooms, & Scallions

Veggie Burger

V → even if you’re not a vegetarian, you won’t miss a thing w/ our healthy ‘impossible’ meat alternative w/ LTO

Green Olive Burger

→ w/ a mix of chopped Green Olives, Mayonnaise, & Seasonings 8oz hand-pressed Patty w/ LTO

The Bronco Burger

→ w/ crispy Bacon, Barbecue Sauce, & Cheddar Cheese 8oz hand-pressed Patty w/ LTO

Old Mill Burger

→ 8oz hand-pressed Patty w/ LTO — or make it a Cheeseburger

The Autumn Burger

→ w/ Brandied Apples, Bacon, & Provolone Cheese

Bourbon-Barbecue Salmon

GF → a half pound Salmon Fillet charbroiled & glazed w/ our own Bourbon Barbecue Sauce, served w/ Long Grain & Wild Rice, & the Vegetable of the day

Smoked Mac & Cheese

V → Cavatappi Noodles tossed w/ a housemade thick & creamy Cheese Sauce made w/ Cheese from off our smoker, w/ a side of Garlic Toast –option to add grilled Chicken; pulled Pork; Barbecue Pulled Pork; Broccoli

Grilled Top Sirloin Steak

GF → half-pound, hand-cut USDA Choice Top Sirloin Steak grilled to your specification, served w/ a Baked Potato, & the Vegetable of the day

Bourbon-Barbecued Ribs

GS → half rack of Pork Ribs, slow-cooked & basted w/ our own Bourbon Barbecue Sauce, served w/ French Fries & housemade Coleslaw

Old Mill’s Famous Wet Burrito

→ A huge 12″ Flour Tortilla stuffed w/ your choice of shredded Chicken or seasoned Ground Beef, & Refried Beans, topped w/ Burrito Sauce, melted Cheddar-Jack Cheese, & all the fixings

Chicken Tenders

→ crispy Chicken Tenders served w/ French Fries & your choice of Dipping Sauce

Grilled Chicken

GF → char-grilled boneless Chicken Breast (1 or 2) made how you like it: Barbecue, Blackened, or Salt & Pepper, served w/ Long Grain and Wild Rice, & the Vegetable of the day

Beer-Battered Perch

→ Crazy-Beaver-Battered Zander Perch Fillets served w/ French Fries, housemade Coleslaw, & Tartar Sauce

Spaghetti & Meatballs

→ a half dozen of our smoked-in-house Pork & Beef Meatballs in our classic housemade Marinara over Spaghetti & topped w/ Parmesan Cheese, w/ a side of Garlic Bread

Kid’s Mac & Cheese

→ served w/ French Fries — for children twelve and under

Kid’s Mini Corn Dogs

→ served w/ French Fries — for children twelve and under

Kid’s Grilled Cheese

→ served w/ French Fries — for children twelve and under

Kid’s Chicken Fingers

→ served w/ French Fries — for children twelve and under

Side of Chips & Salsa

→

Loaded Baked Potato

→

Vegetable of the Day

→

Baked Potato

→

House Side Salad

→ Iceberg, Tomatoes, Scallions, shredded Cheese

Homemade Coleslaw

→

Basket of Sweet Potato Fries

→

Basked of Parmesan-Truffle Fries

→

Basket of French Fries

→

Belgian Waffle of the week

→ Hot Belgian Waffle studded w/ crispy Sugar Pearls, topped w/ this week’s special accompaniments!

Belgian Waffle w/ Caramel Sauce

→ Hot Belgian Waffle studded w/ crispy Sugar Pearls, topped w/ Caramel Sauce

Coffee

→

Hot Tea

→

Iced Tea

→

Lemonade

→

Dr. Pepper

→

Rootbeer

→

Mello Yello

→

Sprite

→

Cherry Coke

→

Diet Coke

→

Coca Cola

→